New Albany and Gahanna residents heating with natural gas may pay less for fuel this winter, but utility rate increases from AEP Ohio and Columbia Gas could eat up those savings.

The U.S. Energy Information Administration's (EIA) 2026-27 Winter Fuels Outlook projects Midwest households heating with natural gas will spend about 10% less this season than last. Lower fuel prices and temperatures similar to last year are the main drivers. Nationally, natural gas heated homes can expect to pay an average of $640 over the five-month heating season, down 9%.

Homes heated with electricity face a different picture. The EIA forecasts a 4% increase in winter electricity bills nationally, driven by a 3% rise in residential electricity prices. Midwest electric-heated homes face a projected seasonal cost of $1,380, up 3%.

"Relatively high natural gas inventories entering the winter season provide a cushion for heating demand, while households that rely on heating oil face higher prices because distillate markets remain tight," EIA Administrator Tristan Abbey said, as reported by Quartz.

Local rate increases stack up

Those federal projections do not account for utility-specific rate changes hitting central Ohio customers.

The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) approved a settlement with AEP Ohio on April 1 that changed the electric utility's rates. Residential customers using 1,000 kilowatt-hours per month initially received a $1.22 monthly credit from tax refunds owed by the utility, the Columbus Dispatch reported. But future infrastructure charges could add more than $10 per month by 2028 if AEP Ohio requests the maximum amount allowed under the settlement, according to a PUCO report cited by the Dispatch.

A separate PUCO decision approved a $7.90 monthly transmission rate increase for AEP Ohio residential customers using 1,000 kWh, the Dispatch reported.

On the gas side, Columbia Gas of Ohio filed a preliminary proposal for a base rate increase with PUCO on Sept. 18. The proposal would raise the monthly base rate by $14.79 to $68.05 in 2028, another $5.11 in 2029 and an additional $4.41 in 2030, the Dispatch reported. Columbia Gas serves nearly 1.5 million customers across 61 of Ohio's 88 counties. A PUCO decision on the rate case is not expected until summer 2027, according to a PUCO spokesperson quoted by the Dispatch.

Data center growth in central Ohio is adding pressure. WOSU reported in January that Meta's Prometheus data center in New Albany requires more than one gigawatt of power to operate, and the company purchased another 429 acres in New Albany and Jersey Township.

Ohio Consumers' Counsel Maureen Willis said utility increases weigh on everyday people. In a statement reported by WOSU, Willis said the PUCO "must never lose sight of the fact that every approved dollar comes directly from consumers' pockets."

How to apply for energy assistance

Ohio runs the federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP) under the name Home Energy Assistance Program (HEAP). Applications for the 2026-2027 season are open through May 31, 2027, according to BenefitsUSA and the Ohio LIHEAP state plan. Key details:

  • Income limit: Household income at or below 175% of federal poverty guidelines. That is $27,930 per year for one person, $37,870 for two, $47,810 for three and $57,750 for four.
  • Regular HEAP: A one-time credit applied to your heating bill. The state plan lists benefits ranging from $31 to $546. Open July 1, 2026, through May 31, 2027.
  • Winter Crisis Program: Emergency help for households facing disconnection or with less than 25% of a tank of bulk fuel. Open Nov. 1, 2026, through March 31, 2027. Requires an appointment with your county's Energy Assistance Provider.
  • PIPP Plus: Customers of PUCO-regulated utilities who qualify can cap their bill at 5% of monthly household income per utility, with a $10 minimum. Applications accepted year-round.
  • How to apply: Online at energyhelp.ohio.gov, by mail to the Office of Community Assistance in Columbus, or in person at your local Energy Assistance Provider.

Ohio has no asset test for HEAP. Savings, retirement accounts and homeownership do not disqualify applicants, according to BenefitsUSA.

Additional utility programs

The Ohio Consumers' Counsel lists several utility-funded programs. AEP Ohio customers can apply for the Neighbor-to-Neighbor Program, which provides up to $500 for households at or below 300% of federal poverty guidelines. Columbia Gas customers may qualify for the HeatShare Program, which offers up to $450 once per year for households at or below 300% of poverty guidelines.

The Dollar Energy Fund's Ohio Utility Assistance Program serves customers of Columbia Gas and AEP Ohio, among other utilities. It provides up to $300 per utility for households with income between 175% and 250% of poverty guidelines who face disconnection.

County crisis funding is limited. BenefitsUSA noted that when Winter Crisis money for a county runs low, agencies stop scheduling appointments. Applying in November rather than waiting until February can make the difference between receiving help and landing on a waitlist.